- Bull
Call Spreads and Bull Put Spreads
© 1999 Kevin Ireland, The American Stock
Exchange
- Most investors are
always looking for new ways to invest in the
market and at the same time limit their risk
exposure. With the stratospheric valuations some
of the more high flying stocks are commanding, it
takes an iron constitution to stay the course. The
buy and hold method of investing in these type of
stocks can be very profitable but leaves the
investor open to an immense amount of downside
risk. Someone who is not willing to accept that
much uncertainty is forced to avoid these stocks
and sit on the sidelines and miss the potential
windfall. Using options in today's market
atmosphere is a way for investors to transfer and
/or reduce risk. Options investors who buy options
recognize the ability to limit risk but are
subjected to paying high premiums in the more
volatile stocks. However, there are a wide range
of option strategies that can lower those high
premiums. Using these strategies provides
opportunities for investors to participate in the
market while limiting downside risk. Two
strategies that we'll discuss are "Bull call
spreads" and "Bull put spreads".
They are considered conservative strategies
because the risk is known and limited and are used
when the investors outlook is mildly bullish. Bull
spreads offer opportunities for profit if the
market advances but at the same time limits the
risk of a market decline.
- Bull Call Spreads
- A bull call spread
is defined as the purchase of a call and the
simultaneous sale of another call on the same
underlying equity with a higher strike and the
same expiration. A bull call spread is always
established as a debit spread. The margin
requirement is the amount paid for the spread
since that is the defined and limited risk of the
spread.
- For example:
XYZ is currently trading at 77. The stock has
risen steadily for the last six months. The
investor thinks the stock can still appreciate but
has significant downside risk. He decides to
establish a bull call spread.
-
- Buy 1 XYZ
1 yr. Call 55 strike
|
- 30
|
- Sell 1 XYZ
1 yr. Call 80 strike
|
- 15
|
- Net Debit
|
- 15
|
|
XYZ
at
Expiration |
1
year 55 Call
Profit/Loss |
1
year 80 Call
Profit/Loss |
Total
Net
Profit/Loss |
|
|
|
|
|
55 |
-30 |
+15 |
-15 |
|
60 |
-25 |
+15 |
-10 |
|
65 |
-20 |
+15 |
-5 |
|
70 |
-15 |
+15 |
0 |
|
75 |
-10 |
+15 |
+5 |
|
80 |
-5 |
+15 |
+10 |
|
85 |
0 |
+10 |
+10 |
|
90 |
+5 |
+5 |
+10 |
The above table shows the
spread is effective for a neutral to mildly bullish
outlook. When selling the 80 strike call to limit
downside risk, the investor has also capped the upside
potential. The maximum value of this spread is the
difference between the two strikes or 25 points. If
the investor pays 15 points for the spread then the
maximum profit would be 10 points.
Why would the investor risk 15 points to make a
maximum of 10? Because of the quantification of risk.
If the investor had only purchased the 55 strike call
at 30 , the breakeven at expiration would be XYZ at
85. Buy selling the 80 strike call at 15 you are
reducing the breakeven at expiration on XYZ to 70.
That means with the stock unchanged at expiration the
investor still realizes a 7 point profit on a 15 point
investment or a 46 % return on equity. And with the
maximum gain being realized with the stock at 80 or
higher at expiration, the investor only needs the
stock to go up 3 points to achieve a maximum profit of
10 points or a 66 % return on equity.
To see how we can achieve these returns we need to
look at time premium. If we pay 30 for the 1 year 55
strike call with the stock at 77 it has an intrinsic
value of 22 points. Then we have paid a time premium
of 8 points. By selling the 1 year 80 strike call at
15 that has no intrinsic value we receive a time
premium of 15 points giving us a positive time premium
of 7 points.
|
XYZ
at 77 |
Buy
55 strike call |
Sell
80 strike call |
|
|
|
|
|
|
Total
premium |
30 |
15 |
|
|
Intrinsic
value |
22 |
0 |
|
|
Time
premium |
-8 |
+15 |
Net
+7 |
Selling more time premium
than we pay out lowers the breakeven, thereby lowering
the total cost of the investment or risk and lowering
the strategic forecast making the best case scenario
more easily achieved. Using bull call spreads in a
volatile market allows the investor to utilize time
premium to his advantage.
Bull Put Spreads
A bull put spread is defined as the selling of a put
and the simultaneous purchase of another put on the
same underlying equity with a lower strike and the
same expiration. A bull put spread is always
established as a credit spread. The margin requirement
for a bull put spread is the amount by which the short
put strike price (higher) exceeds the long put strike
price (lower) less the premium received.
For example:
ABC is currently at 86 ¼ trading down 4 ¼ on the
day. The investor's view is that the downside move is
over and the stock should rally slightly. The annual
high for the stock is 110 and the annual low is 30.
The investor would like to sell a put at this level
with the intention of acquiring the stock at a lower
level but considers there is substantial downside
risk. An alternative is to establish a bull put
spread.
|
Sell
1 ABC 5 month Put 85 strike |
|
16 |
|
Buy
1 ABC 5 month Put 55 strike |
|
4
1/8 |
|
Net
Credit |
|
11
7/8 |
|
ABC
at
Expiration |
5
month 85 strike
Profit/Loss |
5
month 55 strike
Profit/Loss |
Total
Net
Profit/Loss |
|
|
|
|
|
55 |
-14 |
-4
1/8 |
-18
1/8 |
|
60 |
-9 |
-4
1/8 |
-13
1/8 |
|
65 |
-4 |
-4
1/8 |
-8
1/8 |
|
70 |
+1 |
-4
1/8 |
-3
1/8 |
|
75 |
+6 |
-4
1/8 |
+1
7/8 |
|
80 |
+9 |
-4
1/8 |
+4
7/8 |
|
85 |
+16 |
-4
1/8 |
+11
7/8 |
|
90 |
+16 |
-4
1/8 |
+11
7/8 |
The above table shows the
profit and loss at expiration with the stock at
different intervals. Selling the higher put obligates
the investor to buy the stock at the strike price if
assigned. In this instance the strike is 85 and the
investor takes in 16 points in premium for a cost
basis if assigned of 69. The downside risk on this
strategy therefore is 69 points. In order to limit
that risk the investor buys the 55 strike put at 4
1/8. The risk now is the difference between the two
strikes ( 30 points ) less the premium received ( 11
7/8 points ) for a total risk and margin requirement
of 18 1/8 points. This is a neutral strategy with the
objective being the stock remains above 85 through
expiration. If that occurs both options will expire
worthless and the investor will keep the 11 7/8 in
premium. If the stock dips below 85 at expiration the
seller will probably be assigned resulting in the
investor purchasing the stock at 85 less the 11 7/8
premium for an adjusted cost basis of 73 1/8. In this
instance the stock does not have to appreciate for the
investor to achieve a best case scenario.
Again the investor
takes advantage of selling time premium as an
efficient means to effect his strategy. Using options
as the tools to enact the specific strategies while at
the same time quantifying and limiting risk shows the
value that options can add to a portfolio. For the
neutral to mildly bullish investor, bull spreads
afford lower breakevens and lower risk and that's
music to an investors ears.
Kevin Ireland is the Managing Director of
Derivative Securities for the American Stock Exchange
(AMEX) in New York. He can be reached at Kevin.Ireland@Amex.com.
The AMEX web site is www.amex.com. |